Posted by Bonzo on 3/12/2012, 3:08 pm, in reply to "Re: Prove anything?"
I did not say that Righetti's better than Theron in her overall career. She isn't - yet, at least. I merely disagreed with the idea which I seemed to get from your post, that whatever she's doing is irrelevant compared to Theron's achievements. I think she's close enough to be considered a fighter of the same calibre. That was all I was trying to say.
You're putting Cole, Peregrym, Regan (who's only up 2-1 on Amanda, not 2-0) and Palicki as the big four. What about Durance (beaten by Amanda in 2011)? Biel (Amanda's up 2-1 from her early years)? This is surely debatable. As is the fact that you have Palicki as the turning point for Charlize: some would say CT has never been the same after her comeback. We all have different favourites, and different opinions. Besides, Righetti doesn't campaign at lightweight anyway. You're still essentially saying that Amanda's achievements from 2009 to 2012 can't compare with whatever Theron's done. I just can't agree with that. I agree it's unfortunate Righetti/Theron didn't happen in 2009, but I don't think that has the kind of effect on Amanda's reputation you perceive.
Message Thread
« Back to index