I can't ever recall hearing a live performance with cuts - and it's certainly the case most (if not all) recordings today follow the original version (the most recent I have heard, recorded in 2018, is by Toshiyuki Kamioka and it is uncut). Oddly, there is a tendency for Russian conductors to cut some works - if you hear a truncated Manfred, or a performance of Rachmaninoff's Second Symphony with some of the alternative orchestration - it's more than likely to be from a Russian conductor. This is not even of a specific generation - Tugan Sokhiev, for example, shreds Manfred.
As to Isle of the Dead, it's one of those very few works I find can withstand huge fluctuations in tempo and still work. Svetlanov would often take 25 minutes in his last years - but it still works. Many conductors today take 22 or 23 minutes - against a norm of under 20 minutes from a few decades ago. There are many fine performances of it - and that's largely because it's probably the composer's greatest work. It's right up there with pieces like the Sibelius Fourth and the VW Sixth.
Cut or not? Uncut.
« Back to index | View thread »
Thank you for taking part in the MusicWeb International Forum.
Len Mullenger - Founder of MusicWeb