http://www.musicweb-international.com/classrev/2014/Aug14/Arnold_sy3_SDBR3021.htm
The Handley/Conifer set recordings were all amalgamated into an amazing value bargain box from Sony but a quick look implies that that has already gone OOP although again hi-rate downloads seem an (expensive) option.
I agree Song of Simeon is a gem although on that particular recording there's a boy speaker who speaks so orfully orfully neecely that it makes me laugh! I'd like a good new recording of the "Song of Freedom"!
It’s good to see the support for Malcolm Arnold from MusicWeb and Nick Barnard’s comments are no doubt part of the explanation for the lack of centenary celebrations.
But where are the reissues? -especially his own recording of the Third (which I had as a baffled schoolboy close to sixty years ago and would love to hear again) and Handley’s set of the symphonies plus the other Conifer recordings. And then there was the BBC double album including the wonderful ‘Song of Simeon’, surely one of the best Christmas pieces ever.
I was listening to Symphonies 3 and 6 over the last couple of evenings and both seem to me to be outstanding works, masterpieces if you like. Nick’s Shostakovich comparison is entirely apt in many respects and it seems particularly apposite when it comes to his Sixth with its anguished opening movement and circus finale, but in Arnold’s case the high jinks of the finales are underscored by a sense of desperation too that perhaps makes them more a natural outcome of what came before. If only those who decry Arnold would cast aside preconceptions and actually listen, the imagined problems would fall away and they would see the symphonies for the great works they are.
Message Thread
« Back to index | View thread »
Thank you for taking part in the MusicWeb International Forum.
Len Mullenger - Founder of MusicWeb