Hi. I hope you won't mind me adding my 2 cents worth. You won't be replacing Maggie May's memory or love. You will never forget her & you will feel a different love for Mandy May as they each are individuals that can never be exactly duplicated, even with cloning. I also am sure Maggie May would want you to be happy. I lost Colleen to a stroke & had no intention of getting another dog. Sunny just kind of happened (too long to explain tonight). I greatly love him but what I feel for him is different but not less than what I felt for Colleen & my memories of her are still strong 6 years later I am sorry for your loss but grateful that you both had each other for awhiLe.